The students in a fifth-grade SEI class have been studying a unit on chemical reactions and have recently conducted some simple experiments related to the unit. The teacher is reviewing students' written responses to short-answer assignments about the experiments. The following is a representative sample of one English learner's writing.
 
"When the sugar we dissolve in water, the sugar still the sugar is. When the sugar we burn, the sugar not is the sugar anymore. It becomes a new substance. Burning the sugar a chemical reaction is causing."
 
Given this evidence, when planning instruction to improve the student's academic writing, which of the following factors would be most important for the teacher to consider?
  1. The student is having difficulty understanding new academic vocabulary related to the unit and would benefit from vocabulary reinforcement activities.
  2. The student is likely struggling with the concepts underlying the lesson and would benefit from writing assignments that are not content based.
  3. The student is having difficulty applying Standard English writing conventions and would benefit from explicit instruction in punctuation and mechanics.
  4. The student is likely transferring syntactical patterns from the first language and would benefit from explicit instruction in English syntax.
Explanation
Correct Response: D. The student's writing sample provides evidence of difficulty with English word order or syntax. The student misplaces the direct object (sugar) in the first and second sentences and incorrectly places the verb or verb phrase at the end of the clause or sentence in the first, second, and fourth sentences. The consistency of the student's errors suggests that they have likely been caused by first-language interference or "negative transfer." To help the student avoid these errors in future academic writing, the SEI teacher needs to make the student aware that English does not use these syntactic patterns. The teacher should also provide the student with explicit instruction in English syntax (i.e., explicit explanation, examples, and modeling; guided practice with corrective feedback followed by independent practice) related to the correct placement of verbs and direct objects. A and B are incorrect because the student's statements demonstrate appropriate use of academic vocabulary and understanding of the concepts related to the lesson. C is incorrect because the writing sample does not include errors involving punctuation or mechanics (e.g., capitalization, spelling).
Was this helpful? Upvote!
Login to contribute your own answer or details

Top questions

Related questions

Most popular on PracticeQuiz